Understandably, The federal government is even less satisfied once the MIVILUDES is useful for political uses by politicians from the opposition for example Georges Fenech, a rabid anti-cultist who was the mission’s president until eventually 2013 and came back like a member of its Orientation Council in 2021.

Jehovah’s Witnesses allege which the MIVILUDES report applied poor methodology which was calculated to publicly denigrate them and label them being a dangerous cult. The MIVILUDES report ignores the perform of effectively-respected scholars and the judgments of courts of justice in France.[1] in its place, the report’s results are according to unsubstantiated allegations from unreliable anonymous resources.

determined by his experience at MIVILUDES, Bobineau is on the opinion that “MIVILUDES plays the part of the administrative thoughts police, which queries for scapegoats and stigmatizes certain groups.” In an job interview he gave on 8 June 2009, he gave the subsequent clarification:

These bases will be the “saisines” (in principle, alerts by individuals who create to denounce a “cultic deviance”). We now find out the “saisines” aren't authentic “reports.”

still, for 25 yrs MIVILUDEs and its predecessors have tried to export the French design of the “war on cults” to other nations—Ordinarily without having A lot accomplishment, but you can find exceptions.

looking at how the French governmental mission from “cultic deviances” is routinely denounced by main NGOs specialized in spiritual liberty and by governments, together with The usa’, which publish reviews on Worldwide freedom of religion or perception, the declare by its previous president and member of its new steerage Council, Georges Fenech, within an job interview of might 20, that “all the planet envies us [France] for your MIVILUDES” may show up equally as an work out in usual French dark humor.

MIVILUDES may be the point out arm for choosing what on earth is deviant or not, and assigning the “cultic” label. But why would the ethos of churches advocating conventional marriage involving a man and a woman be more deviant compared to words and phrases of Minister Marlène Schiappa, when she stated to the general public, referring for the prohibition of polygamy, that “a few-companion sexual intercourse” could still be practiced?

” this is counted to be a “saisine.” If two university learners on the lookout for substance concerning the team X, and a person town council to which the team X has asked an administrative authorization, contact the MIVILUDES, this helps make 3 “saisines.”

The criteria preferred via the French Renseignements généraux to establish the prospective dangers of the motion were criticized because they have been viewed as vague and should consist of a lot of organizations, spiritual or not. among the first criticisms came from bishop Jean Vernette, the nationwide secretary of your French episcopate for the study of cults and new religious actions, who stressed that these conditions might be placed on Practically all religions. Furthermore, sociologists like Bruno Étienne emphasized that the psychological manipulation should not be outlined by the policemen with the Renseignements généraux.[fifteen] The list of cults was based on the factors defined via the Renseignements généraux, but with out specifying which in their tactics are specially criticized. In addition, the secrecy from the operate produced by the RG triggered questions about the existence or absence of sure corporations during the listing.

MIVILUDES appears to Perform the job of a brain police, through its electric power to differentiate involving “deviant” or “non-deviant” beliefs and techniques.

Considering that followers have misplaced their unique cost-free can even open the doorway on the criminalization of proselytism. To this end, Annex 2 towards the round presents an index of criteria for reporting on the Prosecutor, amongst and that is “Proselytism: the tactic of recruitment of followers, some time invested, the particular targeting, infiltration, using a website.”

They can be just interactions with the MIVILUDES the place the title from the group has actually been talked about. but, the number of “saisines” is a important aspect to include a bunch within the MIVILUDES reports.

La loi 2024-420 du 10 mai 2024 visant à renforcer la lutte contre les dérives sectaires et l’accompagnement des news eurovision victimes constitue un grand progrès pour la prévention et la reconnaissance des droits des victimes de dérives sectaires. ⚖️ Cette loi fait suite au constat du doublement du nombre de signalements et demandes d’info à la MIVILUDES depuis 2015. Ses mesures sont issues des Assises nationales de lutte contre les dérives sectaires. Elle s’inscrit dans la Stratégie nationale de lutte contre les dérives sectaires annoncée par Sabrina Agresti-Roubache, secrétaire d’Etat chargée de la Citoyenneté et de la Ville au mois de novembre dernier. Le Conseil constitutionnel l’a déclaré conforme à la Structure : Ses principales dispositions sont les suivantes : ???? Les missions de la MIVILUDES sont rappelées dans la loi. ???? Nouveauté : les programmes scolaires du secondaire devront intégrer une sensibilisation aux dérives thérapeutiques et sectaires (artwork. 1er). ???? Un nouveau délit de placement ou de maintien en état de sujétion psychologique ou physique est institué. Le responsable de cet état de sujétion sera désormais clairement désignalé. Au-delà des préjudices financiers, le délit sera constitué également lorsqu’il aura causé une altération grave de la santé physique ou psychique (Art. three). La réparation des dommages causés par ces violences sera ainsi facilitée et étendue pour les victimes.

... Ils font use d’une influence morale et psychologique sur un groupe de personnes à des fins financières ou idéologiques.